ગુજરાતની નાડીGujarat PulseThe live pulse of Gujarat politics

PoliticsGandhinagarAhmedabadSuratChhota Udaipur

Morning Pulse: Shah turns Gandhinagar into a jab at Rahul, while the vote shares tell a fuller story

Amit Shah used the BJP's civic sweep to target Rahul Gandhi, but the vote figures show the Congress gaining too and AAP collapsing. The search in the Pirana drain is now in its fifth day, and Surat police have booked 16 alleged fake doctors.

Pan India Pulse deskBased on reports from ANI, Free Press Journal, Bhaskar Live (IANS), India TVગુજરાતીમાં વાંચો

Overnight, Gujarat's civic results stopped being a Gandhinagar story and became a national argument. Union Home Minister Amit Shah used the BJP's sweep to take aim at Rahul Gandhi. The vote-share figures released with the results, though, show something his framing leaves out: the BJP and the Congress both grew, and the Aam Aadmi Party all but disappeared. In Ahmedabad, meanwhile, the search for a child in a city drain has entered its fifth day.

Shah spoke to reporters in New Delhi on Tuesday evening, after our Evening Pulse had gone out. ANI and the Free Press Journal reported that he said the Congress had not won an election in Gujarat in 41 years, and that it last won in 1985. He said the BJP had won 90 of the 104 seats counted across the three local bodies, and he described Gandhinagar as part of his own Lok Sabha constituency. According to both outlets, he linked the result to the opposition's campaign against the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls and asked whether Gandhi would blame the SIR for this result too. Neither report carried a reply from the Congress, and by publication we had not seen one.

The numbers behind the sweep are more mixed than the speech. IANS, carried by Bhaskar Live, and India TV both put the BJP's Gandhinagar vote share at 56.64 percent, the Congress at 37.05 percent and AAP at 4.38 percent. The BJP and the Congress each gained roughly nine to ten points on 2021, while AAP fell from about 22 percent. The two outlets give slightly different 2021 baselines, so we have rounded those figures. Shah's claim of a 10-point rise for the BJP fits the BJP numbers. The Congress's gain is the part of the story he did not mention.

So the anti-BJP vote in the capital did not vanish. It moved from AAP to the Congress. That helps explain how the Congress went from two seats to five while the BJP slipped from 41 to 38, despite polling more votes. Shah also said AAP lost its deposit in all 32 seats it contested. AAP had fielded candidates in only 32 of the 44 seats, as we reported last night.

Several loops from last night are still open. We found no report this morning naming Gandhinagar's mayor, giving a date for the new board's first meeting or saying who will lead the Congress's five-member group. We also found no formal statement on the results from the Congress or AAP state leadership. As of publication, we had seen no new report of police action on the two FIRs against Vadgam MLA Jignesh Mevani.

The tone of politics outside the capital hardened too. Gujarat Samachar and TV9 Gujarati reported remarks by BJP Rajya Sabha MP Mukesh Rathwa at a public event in Chhota Udepur district. A video of the speech has been widely shared. Both outlets reported that he said those who talk of sending the BJP home would not be allowed to step out of their own houses in 2027. Both also reported that he compared his opponents to cockroaches. Gujarat Samachar said his target was AAP leaders who post social media videos about local problems. Neither outlet carried a response from AAP or the BJP.

In Ahmedabad, the visually impaired ten-year-old who fell into an open drain near Pirana on Saturday had still not been found when Gujarat Samachar and Vibes of India reported on Wednesday morning, more than 80 hours into the search. Both reported that methane gas, thick sludge and industrial effluent in the line are slowing rescuers. Cameras lowered into manholes showed nothing through the mud. Teams have moved downstream to the sewage treatment plant's inlet screens and the banks of the Sabarmati. Both reports said municipal engineers suspect chemicals are reaching the sewer through unauthorised industrial connections or illegal night dumping by tankers. That suspicion is unconfirmed. Neither report mentioned an inquiry or a public statement from the Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation.

In Surat, police and health officials raided clinics in Pandesara and booked 16 people accused of practising medicine without qualifications, IANS and Gujarat First reported late on Tuesday. Police said some had studied only up to Class 10 or 12 and had earlier worked as compounders. One allegedly ran a clinic for 33 years. Medicines and equipment worth more than Rs 1.8 lakh were seized, and cases were registered at Pandesara police station.

Pulse view

Analysis by the Pulse desk

Shah's speech was aimed past Gujarat at Delhi. A civic result in his own constituency became an answer to the opposition's complaints about the voter-roll revision. That is ordinary politics, and the BJP's margin backs it up. But the speech leaves out the Congress's gain in Gandhinagar. A 37 percent vote share is not what a party heading for oblivion looks like. The figures point to a two-party contest returning, with AAP squeezed out in between. That could make the 2027 Assembly fight sharper rather than easier for the ruling party.

Rathwa's words show the other side of a lopsided win. The more secure a party feels, the louder some of its members get, and talk of keeping opponents indoors sits badly with a contest the BJP has just won comfortably. The quieter stories make the same point about power. A child is lost in a drain the city runs, and Surat's clinics allegedly went unchecked for decades. These failures belong to whoever governs. Big majorities do not make them anyone's job.

So for readers: when one party wins this easily, who should be expected to keep asking why a drain was open or a fake clinic ran for 33 years: the small opposition, the press, or the voters themselves?

What they are saying

The Aam Aadmi Party contested all 32 seats but forfeited its security deposit on every single one of them.

Amit Shah, Union Home Minister, ANI

The last election they won was back in 1985; since then, they have faced continuous defeats in Gujarat.

Amit Shah, Union Home Minister, ANI

What to watch

  • Who the BJP names as Gandhinagar mayor, and when the new board first meets
  • Whether the Congress replies to Shah and names its opposition leader in the corporation
  • Any AAP response to its vote-share collapse and to Mukesh Rathwa's remarks
  • The Pirana search, and whether the AMC or the state orders an inquiry into the open drain and the suspected industrial dumping
  • Further action by Surat's health department against unregistered clinics

Your take

Do you agree with the Pulse view?

Sources

  1. "Congress hasn't won a single election in 41 years in Gujarat": Amit Shah targets Rahul Gandhi after BJP's local poll sweep ANI
  2. Amit Shah Hits Out At Rahul Gandhi After BJP's Gujarat Poll Win, Says Congress Has Lost For 41 Years Free Press Journal
  3. Civic poll results reflect trust in BJP's development agenda: Gujarat CM (IANS) Bhaskar Live (IANS)
  4. Gandhinagar Municipal Corporation Election: BJP gets over 57% vote share, Congress 37%, AAP just 4% India TV
  5. MP Mukesh Rathwa's harsh attack on AAP from a public platform in Chhota Udepur (Gujarati) Gujarat Samachar
  6. MP Mukesh Rathwa's remarks against the opposition go viral (Gujarati) TV9 Gujarati
  7. Over 80 Hours On: Methane Gas, Chemical Sludge Hinder Rescue of Visually Impaired 10-Year-Old Girl From Drain in Ahmedabad's Pirana Gujarat Samachar (English)
  8. 80 Hours, No Trace: Visually Impaired 10-Year-Old Girl Missing Near Ahmedabad's Pirana Methane Dumping Yard Vibes of India
  9. Surat: SOG raid in Pandesara catches 16 bogus doctors (Gujarati) Gujarat First
  10. 'Earning up to Rs 40,000 a day, practising for decades': 16 fake doctors caught in Gujarat (IANS) SocialNews.XYZ (IANS)

Open live Gujarat Pulse