PoliticsDelhi
Morning Pulse: The CJI says no to a meeting, so the opposition marches to the court's gate
Chief Justice Surya Kant has declined to meet Rahul Gandhi and Mallikarjun Kharge over the voter-roll row. The INDIA bloc marches to the Supreme Court at 1:30 pm, with six central Delhi metro stations shut.
Pan India Pulse deskBased on reports from Business Standard, ThePrint (PTI), The Week, Business Today
Since last night, the opposition's Monday plan has lost its centrepiece. Rahul Gandhi and Mallikarjun Kharge, the Leaders of Opposition in the Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha, had written to Chief Justice of India Surya Kant asking to meet him between 4 and 5 pm today. Late on Sunday, sources in the court told PTI that the CJI had turned them down. The march goes ahead anyway.
The reason given, again through unnamed sources, was that similar questions about the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls are already before the Supreme Court. The CJI reportedly said no orders can be passed on the administrative side and that the court cannot step into executive functions that way. He pointed the leaders to the judicial route: file a petition, which could be heard with the SIR matters listed for Tuesday. A source added that a reply had gone to the leaders' official email. There is no on-record statement from the court yet.
The memorandum the two leaders wanted to hand over carries four demands. They want an end to what they call "vote chori" (vote theft), the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, a halt to the SIR, and a return to paper ballots. The last of these goes well beyond the Cockroach Janta Party (CJP) protests that started this week's confrontation, which focused on the CEC.
The march itself, which the Congress calls "Chalo Delhi - March for Democracy", is set to gather at the Connaught Place-Barakhamba Road junction at 1:30 pm and head for the Supreme Court. Rahul Gandhi said civil society groups and young people would join party workers. Kharge, speaking in Bengaluru, said the leaders would only plead their case before the CJI, not make demands, and accused the Prime Minister and Home Minister of creating chaos across the country.
Delhi is bracing again. The Delhi Metro Rail Corporation has shut entry and exit at six stations from 6 am to 4 pm: Rajiv Chowk, Janpath, Patel Chowk, Mandi House, Central Secretariat and Barakhamba Road. Interchanges stay open, and DMRC says security agencies will review the position through the day. Traffic police have warned of diversions across New and Central Delhi from 6 am. Last evening's question of whether the INDIA bloc would get formal permission for the march remains unanswered in public; no police statement on it had been reported by morning.
The closures land in an awkward spot. On Sunday the same Supreme Court bench, Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana, found a prima facie case of contempt over Saturday's metro and rail curbs, which a petitioner said broke the court's October 9 order against a full transport shutdown. Notice went to Union Home Secretary Govind Mohan, Delhi Police Commissioner Anurag Kumar and DMRC chief D Thara. Solicitor General Tushar Mehta told the court that 45 of 303 stations were closed on Saturday for law and order and all reopened by 10 pm. Today's six closures are far fewer, but they will be part of the record on Tuesday.
The scale of Saturday is also being revised. A PTI report on Sunday night put detentions in Delhi that day at more than 7,000, well above earlier counts. Kharge said about 32,000 police and 7,500 CRPF personnel were deployed. The Election Commission has still not responded publicly to the demand for the CEC's resignation.
Beyond politics, two things to track today. The September retail inflation figure is due this evening; economists polled by Mint expected a jump to around 5.6% from 4.82% in August, which would sharpen the pressure on prices that voters feel directly. In cricket, India beat West Indies by 14 runs in Indore on Sunday night to lead the T20I series 2-1, with Abhishek Sharma scoring 69 off 30 balls and Arshdeep Singh taking three wickets. The fourth match is on Wednesday.
Pulse view
Analysis by the Pulse deskThe CJI's refusal follows a familiar rule. Judges hear cases; they do not take memoranda from political leaders on matters pending before them. Meeting the two Leaders of Opposition a day before a hearing on the same subject would have invited questions about the court's distance from politics, whichever side was knocking. Seen that way, the court has protected its own standing, and it has left the door open through a petition.
Still, the opposition gets something out of the refusal. A march to a court that has said no turns the day into a public appeal, and the court has, in fact, been the one institution to push back on the Delhi administration this week, from Sunday's directions to the contempt notice. The government's side has its own case: police say large unauthorised gatherings need control, and the Solicitor General argued that most of the metro stayed open. The irony is that both camps now point to the same bench as proof they are right.
Tuesday's hearing is where the questions converge: compliance with the court's orders, alleged illegal detentions, and possibly a fresh petition from the opposition itself. If the court is the only forum both sides accept, should political disputes over voter lists be settled there, or does that ask too much of judges?
What they are saying
Tomorrow, we will march to the Supreme Court as Indians, united beyond party, gender, caste, community and state.
We can only request him with folded hands,
The situation will be reviewed by the security agencies and necessary updates will be shared accordingly.
What to watch
- Whether the 1:30 pm INDIA bloc march reaches the Supreme Court, and how Delhi Police handle it.
- Whether the opposition files a petition on the judicial side, as the CJI reportedly suggested, in time for Tuesday.
- Tuesday 13 Oct: Supreme Court hears the contempt notice over metro and rail curbs, the detention petitions and compliance reports.
- September CPI inflation data this evening, against expectations of a sharp rise.
- Any public response from the Election Commission to the resignation demand.
Your take
Do you agree with the Pulse view?
Sources
- CJI Surya Kant declines to meet Rahul Gandhi, Kharge over 'vote chori' Business Standard
- Opposition to march to SC to demand end to 'vote chori'; CJI declines to meet Rahul, Kharge ThePrint (PTI)
- Oppn to march to Supreme Court to demand end to 'vote chori'; Kharge, Rahul seek time to meet CJI ThePrint (PTI)
- INDIA bloc's Supreme Court march: Six metro stations shut; police issue traffic advisory The Week
- Delhi metro closes 6 major stations ahead of Opposition's Supreme Court march today Business Today
- Prima facie contempt case made out over Delhi Metro restrictions during protests, says Supreme Court Bar and Bench
- CEC Protest: Supreme Court issues notice on contempt plea against Union, Delhi Police authorities over Metro and train curbs LiveLaw
- India's retail inflation may have increased to a 23-month high of 5.6% in September The Wire
- India vs West Indies 3rd T20I: India hold their nerve to clinch 14-run victory Outlook India
- Arshdeep and Abhishek power India to 2-1 lead ESPNcricinfo