PoliticsMumbaiPuneSolapurBeed
Evening Pulse: Mumbai's crackdown, a shrinking voter roll and a dry Maharashtra
Hundreds were detained in Mumbai over two days of protests against the Chief Election Commissioner. Monday is the last day to fix your name on the draft voter roll, and the drought is now in 265 talukas.
Pan India Pulse deskBased on reports from ThePrint (PTI), Business Standard (PTI), Vividh Bharathi (IANS), India.com
Maharashtra had three big stories this weekend, and they are more connected than they look: a police crackdown on protesters in Mumbai, a voter roll that has shrunk sharply, and a drought that is pushing rural families to the edge.
Start with Mumbai. On Saturday police detained around 400 to 600 people, according to police figures reported by PTI, at August Kranti Maidan, Hutatma Chowk and other spots where people gathered in support of the Cockroach Janta Party's protest against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. Among them were Tushar Gandhi, who was held for about eight to nine hours before being released, and actor Imran Khan. Police said August Kranti Maidan is not a designated protest site under a Bombay High Court order. An FIR has been filed at Gamdevi police station naming Imran Khan, Lekha Washington and others for disobeying orders and unlawful assembly. On Sunday activist Anjali Damania and dozens of others were detained at Shivaji Park.
The opposition reacted sharply. Shiv Sena (UBT) leader Aaditya Thackeray went to a police station to demand Tushar Gandhi's release and said an emergency had been unofficially imposed. Sanjay Raut called it an Emergency-like situation and demanded an apology from Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis. NCP (SP) working president Supriya Sule called the detentions cowardly, and Congress leader Nana Patole said the Modi government was frightened. We did not find an on-record response from the BJP, Shiv Sena or NCP in the reports we read.
Now the voter roll, which is what the protest is about. Monday, October 12, is the last day to file claims and objections in Maharashtra's Special Intensive Revision (SIR). The draft roll lists 7.72 crore electors, against 9.79 crore before the revision, IANS reported. Notices have gone to 1.22 crore voters. The Election Commission has fixed a glitch that showed 2.7 lakh voters, most of them in three Nashik constituencies, as aged over 100, so they do not need to file fresh forms. Claims will be decided by November 10 and the final roll is due on November 16.
Then there is the drought, now declared in 265 talukas. Chief Minister Fadnavis has met the central assessment team that toured districts including Ahilyanagar, Solapur, Jalna, Beed, Dharashiv, Washim and Yavatmal. The state will send a detailed memorandum seeking central relief. Soybean, cotton, tur and sugarcane are hit, and rabi sowing is at risk. Drinking water has been reserved until August 2027, and the state may buy fodder from other states.
Nationally, the Supreme Court on Sunday told Delhi authorities not to detain peaceful protesters outside the law. Sanjay Raut said he would join the INDIA bloc protest in Delhi on Monday.
Pulse view
Analysis by the Pulse deskThe protests are about trust, but Monday's deadline is about paperwork. Whatever one thinks of the SIR, a voter whose name is missing has one more day to file a claim. That practical fact matters more to most families than any slogan, and parties on both sides could do more to help people check their names.
The size of the gap deserves a calm, public explanation. A roll about two crore names shorter could reflect duplicates and people who moved or died, or it could include eligible voters who were left out. Only detailed, published data can tell the two apart.
And here is the question that links the three stories: in a drought year, when many rural workers leave home in search of work, who is most likely to miss a voter-roll notice? The answer may decide whose voice is counted when Maharashtra next votes.
What they are saying
Overall, around 600 people were detained from various spots across the city,
An emergency has been unofficially imposed. Why are they so afraid of the youth generation?
I condemn this act because it was a very peaceful agitation.
Water sources have dried up in several parts of Maharashtra, particularly in small rural villages,
What to watch
- Monday's SIR deadline and whether it is extended
- Any Mahayuti response to the opposition's charges over the Mumbai detentions
- The central team's drought report and the state's memorandum
- Whether MNS and MVA workers stage more protests in Mumbai this week
Your take
Do you agree with the Pulse view?
Sources
- Tushar Gandhi, actor Imran Khan among 600 people detained for protesting in Mumbai in CJP's support ThePrint (PTI)
- Tushar Gandhi, actor Imran Khan among 400 detained in Mumbai protests Business Standard (PTI)
- Tushar Gandhi detained and released after eight hours Vividh Bharathi (IANS)
- Imran Khan, Lekha Washington named in FIR after Mumbai protest at August Kranti Maidan India.com
- Protest in support of CJP: Anjali Damania, several others detained at Mumbai's Shivaji Park The Tribune (PTI)
- 'Cowardly act': Supriya Sule, Sanjay Raut, Aaditya Thackeray slam Centre over anti-CEC protest crackdown Free Press Journal (PTI)
- Hitler did the same during his final days: Sanjay Raut calls situation in India Emergency-like ANI
- EC resolves age-related discrepancies for 2.7 lakh voters in Maharashtra before deadline ap7am (IANS)
- 2.7 lakh Maharashtra voters' age over 100 in SIR Gujarat Samachar
- Maharashtra govt to submit detailed memorandum for central drought relief ThePrint (PTI)