PoliticsMumbaiPune
Morning Pulse: Voter roll window reopens to Oct 26 as Thackerays keep Shivaji Park protest going
The Election Commission gave Maharashtra two more weeks for SIR claims and objections, but kept the 16 November final roll date. Sena (UBT) and MNS held a second day of protest in Mumbai, and the Supreme Court takes up SIR matters today.
Pan India Pulse deskBased on reports from ThePrint (PTI), Free Press Journal, LiveLaw, ANI
A correction to where we left things last night. We reported that Maharashtra's window for voter roll claims and objections had closed with no extension. A little later on Monday evening, the Election Commission of India pushed the deadline to 26 October, ThePrint and the Free Press Journal reported, citing PTI. The final roll will still be published on 16 November. That means there is no final count of claims yet, because the window is open again.
Under the revised schedule, notices and the disposal of claims must be finished by 10 November, both reports said. The state's Chief Electoral Officer urged eligible citizens, especially first-time voters, to use the extra time to add their names, fix errors or file objections. Neither report gave the Commission's reason for the extension, and no fresh tally of forms has been published. The last public figure remains about 6.24 lakh forms up to 4 October.
The extension gives voters more time but squeezes the officials. Two more weeks of filings now have to be checked inside the same window before the final roll. Opposition parties have alleged that eligible voters are being wrongly dropped. The added time answers part of that complaint. It does not answer their main demand, which is a halt to the exercise.
In Mumbai, the protest did not stop after the FIR. Shiv Sena (UBT) and the MNS returned to Shivaji Park on Monday for a second straight day, ThePrint (PTI) and the Free Press Journal reported. Sena (UBT) workers held a silent protest with black ribbons over their mouths. MNS chief Raj Thackeray led a signature campaign seeking the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. Aaditya, Tejas, Raj and Amit Thackeray all signed the registers, the Free Press Journal said. Aaditya Thackeray said the agitation would go on until the CEC steps down.
The tone was different from Sunday. The Free Press Journal reported that no one was detained at Shivaji Park on Monday and that fewer police were deployed. It put the crowd at about 600 people. The MNS calls its drive a statewide campaign. Its demands include cancelling the SIR in Maharashtra and returning to paper ballots. One MNS leader, Mahesh Bhanushali, alleged that Sakinaka police stopped the drive in Chandivali and took down banners. We found no police response to that claim. The bandh threat Aaditya Thackeray made on Sunday was not acted on.
The FIR we flagged last night, against 25 people including Aaditya and Amit Thackeray, has not moved. We found no reports of summons, arrests or court steps. Police have charged them with unlawful assembly and breaking police orders. None of these charges has been tested in court.
Today's main event is in Delhi. The petition filed on Monday by 11 INDIA bloc leaders, including Sanjay Raut and Supriya Sule, does not yet have a listing date of its own. LiveLaw and ANI reported that related SIR matters are listed for hearing on Tuesday. They said the Chief Justice indicated the new plea could be taken up with them or at the earliest opportunity. According to LiveLaw, the plea seeks a suspension of the SIR in every state, booth-wise lists of deleted voters with reasons, and an audit led by a retired Supreme Court judge. India TV reported late on Monday, however, that the registry had flagged 14 defects in the new plea, including a Rs 220 court-fee shortfall, and that it was unlikely to be mentioned on Tuesday. The Election Commission had not filed a reply in the reports we checked. Raut told ANI the court was the opposition's 'ray of hope'.
Two other files were quiet overnight. The Justice Dilip Bhosale panel on the MPSC still has no publicly reported deadline. On the drought, we found no date yet for the central team's report or for the inter-ministerial meeting that Union Home Minister Amit Shah promised would be held soon.
Pulse view
Analysis by the Pulse deskThe extension helps both sides make their case. The Election Commission can say it has listened and given voters more time. The opposition can say the extension proves the process was rushed. The one fixed point is 16 November. If officials must process more claims in the same window, the quality of those decisions matters more than ever, and that is the very thing the INDIA bloc wants the Supreme Court to examine.
In Mumbai, the change from Sunday to Monday says something too. Fewer police and no detentions meant a calmer protest. The quieter approach takes the edge off the opposition's charge that the government is suppressing dissent. It also avoids handing the Thackerays more pictures of confrontation. For the cousins, a signature drive is a steadier tool than a bandh during Navratri. But it also tests whether their anger over the voter rolls can draw ordinary people beyond the party faithful.
If the Supreme Court leaves the SIR in place but tightens how deletions are handled, would that be enough to settle the doubts about Maharashtra's voter rolls?
What they are saying
These protests will continue until Gyanesh Kumar resigns.
I do not understand why this happened or under whose pressure.
the Supreme Court is our ray of hope
What to watch
- Today's Supreme Court hearing on related SIR matters, and when the INDIA bloc petition naming Sanjay Raut and Supriya Sule clears the registry's 14 defects.
- Whether the state election office publishes a running count of claims and objections now that the window runs to 26 October.
- How far the MNS signature campaign spreads beyond Mumbai, and whether police respond to the allegation that the drive was stopped in Chandivali.
- A formal deadline for the Justice Dilip Bhosale MPSC panel, and the date of its first sitting.
- A date for the inter-ministerial meeting on Maharashtra's drought relief request.
Your take
Do you agree with the Pulse view?
Sources
- SIR: Maharashtra extends deadline for claims, objections on draft voter list to Oct 26 ThePrint (PTI)
- Maharashtra Voter Roll: ECI Extends Claims Deadline To October 26; Final Electoral List On November 16 Free Press Journal
- Shiv Sena (UBT), MNS stage protest at Shivaji Park on second consecutive day ThePrint (PTI)
- Mumbai: Shiv Sena (UBT) And MNS Hold Silent Protest At Dadar's Shivaji Park Over Alleged Voter List Manipulation Free Press Journal
- Maharashtra: MNS Launches Statewide Signature Campaign Seeking CEC Gyanesh Kumar's Resignation Free Press Journal
- Rahul Gandhi & INDIA Bloc Leaders Move Supreme Court Against ECI Over SIR Process LiveLaw
- Thousands join 'March for Democracy' as INDIA bloc petitions Supreme Court against ECI amid SIR row ANI
- Missing signatures to Rs 220 fee shortfall: 14 defects flagged in INDIA bloc SIR petition India TV
- Maharashtra Forms Panel To Overhaul MPSC Deccan Chronicle
- Maharashtra govt to submit detailed memorandum for Central drought relief ThePrint (PTI)