भारत की नब्ज़India PulseThe live pulse of Indian politics

PoliticsDelhiUttarakhandSikkim

Morning Pulse: The Supreme Court makes the poll panel answer, and the street gets its turn at 5 pm

The Supreme Court issued notice to the Election Commission on the SIR petitions but paused nothing. Rahul Gandhi took the Ankita Bhandari row to the President, and the CJP's Tiranga call has Delhi on alert.

Pan India Pulse deskBased on reports from The Week, Onmanorama, ANI, ETV Bharatहिन्दी में पढ़ें

The voter-roll fight got half of what it went to court for. On Thursday the Supreme Court issued notice to the Election Commission and Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, so the Commission must now defend the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) in writing. It did not stop the exercise, and it had pointed words for the petitioners too. Today the argument goes back outdoors: the Cockroach Janta Party (CJP) has called a "Lehra Do Tiranga" gathering at Connaught Place at 5 pm, and Delhi has spent the night getting ready for it. The thread is the one we followed yesterday: who may protest, and who may question the referee.

Since yesterday's Morning Pulse, the bench of Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justice Joymalya Bagchi has tagged the INDIA bloc's petitions with the SIR challenges already pending from several states, The Week and Onmanorama reported. The petitioners include Rahul Gandhi, Mallikarjun Kharge, Akhilesh Yadav, Tejashwi Yadav, Sanjay Raut and Supriya Sule. Neither report mentions interim relief or a fresh hearing date. The Chief Justice said a notice was not a finding against anyone. The demand for the Commission's internal files, including objections reportedly recorded by Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, now travels with the main case.

The sharpest words were for one petitioner. The court said it would accept notice for him only provisionally, until he explained his conduct over the crowd at the court premises after Monday's march. The Week identified him as Rahul Gandhi and reported the Chief Justice saying nobody can browbeat the judiciary; Onmanorama did not name him. On the protest pleas, the bench issued notice to the Centre and Delhi Police over removing Jantar Mantar from the list of protest sites. Solicitor General Tushar Mehta told the court the decision rested on a committee report and was not arbitrary, The Week reported.

The Ankita Bhandari row reached Rashtrapati Bhavan. Rahul Gandhi wrote to President Droupadi Murmu on Thursday asking her to have the government reconsider Dushyant Kumar Gautam's appointment as Governor of Sikkim, and to keep him from taking office until the CBI finishes its probe into the 2022 murder, ANI and ETV Bharat reported. His case rests on immunity: a sitting governor cannot face criminal proceedings, so the post would, he argued, put Gautam out of reach. He invoked Article 74(1) and accused the Prime Minister of showing no concern for women's safety.

The parents' 24-hour ultimatum, issued after police removed them from India Gate before dawn on Thursday, runs out about now. Ankita's father told ANI that if it went unanswered, the people of Uttarakhand would come out onto the streets. The family also wants call and location records for Gautam and another man for 18-19 September 2022 made public. Neither ANI nor ETV Bharat carried a response from the BJP, the government or Gautam, and we found none overnight. As we reported yesterday, Gautam denies any involvement and has gone to court for defamation; no court has linked him to the case.

Now Connaught Place. The Delhi High Court on Thursday declined a Palika Bazaar vendor's plea to stop the CJP gathering, recording the police's assurance that they would take all possible measures to manage it, Outlook reported; the matter returns on 3 November. The New Delhi Municipal Council has shut Central Park on Friday and Saturday, citing administrative reasons, and traffic police have warned of disruption around CP from 3 pm, The Statesman reported. Police cited prohibitory orders under Section 163 of the BNSS but signalled that a limited group might carry the flag and sing the anthem at another spot. The AAP has backed the call.

That loop from yesterday stays open: CJP co-convenors Saurav Das and Ashutosh Ranka remain in judicial custody in Tihar after their arrest over entering Jantar Mantar, Outlook and The Statesman reported. Police cite trespass, breach of prohibitory orders and of peace bonds. We found no report of a bail hearing yet.

Markets had their best day in four months on Thursday. The Sensex rose 1,533.72 points (2.11%) to 74,315.61 and the Nifty 374.65 points to 22,997.35 as Brent fell more than 2% during the day, Kotak Neo reported. HDFC Sky noted that falling shares still outnumbered rising ones and that Brent was near $105.5 early on Friday, still above $100; GIFT Nifty pointed to a muted-to-firm start. Wipro's September-quarter profit slipped 1.4% to Rs 3,200.6 crore while revenue rose 9.1%, but large-deal bookings fell 58.6% from the previous quarter and its guidance ranges from a 1.5% fall to 0.5% growth, Business Standard and Business Today reported. PNB, LTIMindtree, Federal Bank and DLF report today.

Pulse view

Analysis by the Pulse desk

The court gave each side something and neither side everything. The opposition wanted the Commission made to answer on paper, and it now must. The Commission wanted the SIR left running, and it is. The irony is that the march meant to show the court how urgent the matter was became the one thing the court asked a petitioner to explain. A bench that says notice is not condemnation, and in the same hearing warns against browbeating, is telling both camps it will set its own pace.

The Ankita Bhandari letter and the CJP's Tiranga call test the same pressure point from different sides. The government's position is that a governor's appointment is a constitutional act and that protest sites are a matter of public order, with courts open to anyone aggrieved. The protesters' position is that immunity, closed parks and de-listed venues add up to avoiding questions. Under Article 74(1) the President can send advice back once, but must act on what the Cabinet says after that, so Rahul Gandhi's letter is more a political marker than a likely legal route. Connaught Place this evening is the more immediate test: the High Court has put the police's promise to regulate, not prevent, on its record.

When the highest court opens a case but lets the disputed process keep running, does that cool the argument, or send it back to the streets until the next hearing?

What they are saying

Issuing notice does not mean that we are condemning anything

Surya Kant, Chief Justice of India, The Week

Article 74(1) gives you the power to ask the government to reconsider its advice

Rahul Gandhi, Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha, in a letter to President Droupadi Murmu, ETV Bharat

The strategic investments we have been making are beginning to deliver results.

What to watch

  • 5 pm, Central Park, Connaught Place: turnout at the CJP's "Lehra Do Tiranga" call, how police handle it, and any detentions.
  • Any reply from the Centre, the BJP or Dushyant Kumar Gautam to Ankita Bhandari's parents and to Rahul Gandhi's letter, and whether Gautam is sworn in as Sikkim Governor.
  • The Election Commission's written reply, the date for the tagged SIR batch, and the petitioner's explanation of his conduct that the court sought.
  • Bail for CJP co-convenors Saurav Das and Ashutosh Ranka.
  • Results from PNB, LTIMindtree, Federal Bank and DLF, and whether Brent stays above $100.

Your take

Do you agree with the Pulse view?

Sources

  1. SIR row: SC seeks answers from ECI, asks Rahul Gandhi to explain march The Week
  2. SC issues notice to ECI, Gyanesh Kumar on INDIA bloc leaders' pleas against SIR Onmanorama
  3. Don't allow Dushyant Gautam to assume Governor's office until investigation in Ankita Bhandari case is complete: Rahul Gandhi urges President ANI
  4. Rahul Gandhi Writes To President Murmu Asking To Reconsider Dushyant Gautam's Appointment ETV Bharat
  5. Delhi on alert for CJP's Tiranga protest: Central Park shut, traffic curbs from 3 pm, heavy security at CP The Statesman
  6. Delhi HC Declines To Stop CJP's October 16 Protest At Connaught Place Outlook
  7. Pre-Market 16 October 2026: GIFT Nifty Hints At Higher Opening As Oil Prices And Q2 Earnings In Focus Kotak Neo
  8. Gift Nifty Points to Muted-to-Positive Open for Sensex, Nifty on Friday HDFC Sky
  9. Wipro Q2 results: Net profit falls 1.4% to ₹3,200.6 cr, revenue rises 9% Business Standard
  10. Wipro Q2 profit slips slightly YoY to Rs 3,201 crore; revenue climbs 9% Business Today

Open live India Pulse